byte-n

The open review comment

A draft is declared ready while a material question remains unanswered.

Short journal · Original editorial · Things we can finish

A draft is declared ready while a material question remains unanswered.

A stopping point makes an attempt assessable. Define what must be present, what can wait, and how the recipient will know the work is ready. A finish is a boundary for this version; it need not be the end of all possible improvement.

Resolve the question or state the limitation explicitly.

You can stop after one small attempt. The purpose is to make a particular choice clearer, not to create a new obligation.

Try a question

What would you notice after trying this in one small, real situation?